Although many clinical data have shown that femtosecond laser-assisted corneal refractive surgery is a safe and effective method for ammetropia, it still should be confirmed further by clinical data that shows visual quality can be improved by femtosecond laser-assisted corneal refractive surgery compared with the conventional procedure. The key points to improve visual quality after femtosecond laser-assisted refractive surgery are clarified in this article. The technique should be approached by proceeding in a rational manner to provide perfect visual quality for the patients while avoiding complications.
Objective To evaluate the corneal aberrations after femtosecond LASIK for myopia and myopia astigmatism with a wavefront optimized profile. Methods Prospective study including 30 eyes from 30 patients (mean 20.9±2.8 years) with myopia (mean spherical equivalent refractive -6.48±1.61 D). The asphericity (Q value) of the anterior corneal surface for patients with different corneal diameters (6, 7, 8 and 9 mm) were measured with Pentacam. Higher-order aberrations (HOAs) of the corneal were measured with the Keratron at 6 mm pupil diameter. Postoperative changes in corneal HOAs and corneal asphericity were analyzed during 3 months follow up. Paired t test was used to analysis the pre- and post-operative data. Pearson correlation was used to investigate correlations between Q values, corneal aberrations and other data. Results At 6 mm pupil diameter significant increases in corneal HOAs, whole spherical aberration (WSA), whole coma (WComa), C3+1, C3-1, C40、 C4+2, C5+1, C5-1, C60 were observed 3 months after surgery (t=-8.254, -7.385, -6.108, -5.651, -2.195, -7.565, -4.628, -2.974, -2.748, -7.068, P<0.05). Corneal asphericity for 6, 7, 8, 9 mm also increased significantly (t=16.999, -19.208, -21.502, -22.197, P<0.05). At 6 mm pupil diameter significant correlations were found between Q change(△Q6 mm) and HOA change (△HOA), WSA change (△WSA), C40 change (△C40), WCom change (△WComa) (r=0.736, 0.792, 0.788, 0.383, P<0.05). No correlation between △Q6 mm and whole trefoil change (△WTrefoil), C60 change (△C60) (r=0.099, -0.348, P>0.05). Conclusion Femtosecond LASIK using a wavefront optimized ablation profile yielded excellent visual outcomes. A significant induction of corneal HOAs still exists.
Objective To compare optical quality and objective intraocular scattering after femtosecond laser in situ keratomileusis (FS-LASIK) and implantable collamer lenses (ICL) implantation for high myopia. Methods This observational case-control study selected 44 consecutive patients (ages range from 18 to 40 years) with myopia between -6 D to -12 D, of which 24 cases (48 eyes) accepted FS-LASIK surgery and 20 cases (40 eyes) underwent ICL implantation. In addition to the corneal thickness (t=4.77, P<0.05), all the preoperative data were matched between the two groups. Measurements were performed one and three-month postoperatively by a double-pass optical quality analysis system (OQASTM, Visiometrics, Spain). We assessed the objective scattering index (OSI), modulation transfer function (MTF) cutoff frequency, Strehl ratio and OQAS values (OVs) at contrasts of 100%, 20% and 9%. Paired t test for data comparison within group and independent sample t test between groups were used for statistical analysis in postoperative 3 months follow-up. Results After 1 month, except for residual mild astigmatism (t=4.95, P<0.05) and more safety index (t=2.22, P<0.05) in ICL group, no significant differences were found between the groups in UCVA, BSCVA and equivalent sphere refraction. After 3 months, while no significant change of equivalent sphere refraction in ICL group compared with 1 month, 50% eyes in FS-LASIK group had an average refractive regression of -0.72±0.72 D. We also found no significant differences in the MTF cutoff frequency, Strehl ratio, 100%OVs, 20%OVs, and 9%OVs between groups after 1 and 3 months, only OSI of ICL surgery after 1 month was greater than FS-LASIK group (t=2.14, P<0.05). Conclusion Either FS-LASIK or ICL implantation could effectively correct high myopia range from -6 D to -12 D; However, ICL implantation was safer and more stable when compared with FS-LASIK surgery. Although early objective intraocular scattering after ICL implanted was slightly higher, the overall results of postoperative optical quality were similar.
Objective To analyze the effect of a “no trim” design in the optical ablation zone on postoperative visual quality in patients who have undergone femtosecond microlens resection surgery, especially with dilated pupils. Methods This was a prospective cohort study. Postoperative visual quality was measured in 3 groups of patients (a total of 104 cases, 208 eyes) that included a thin flap LASIK group (38 patients, 76 eyes), a femtosecond LASIK group (28 patients, 56 eyes) and a femtosecond laser surgery small incision lens (SMILE) group (38 patients, 76 eyes). Excimer laser cutting equipment was used in the thin flap LASIK group, optical zoom was 6.0 mm, transition zone was 1.25 mm; femtosecond laser was used for the corneal flap in the femtosecond LASIK group, optical zoom was 6.0 mm, transition zone was 1.25 mm; and femtosecond laser was used in the SMILE group for refractive microlens (6.0 mm) fabrication. Postoperative assessments included uncorrected visual acuity, contrast sensitivity (CS), glare sensitivity (GS) and wavefront aberration measurements for normal (≤5 mm) and dilated (≥7 mm) pupils. SPSS 15.0 statistical software was used for statistical analysis. Distribution normality was tested (x±s), and then one-way ANOVA was used for overall analysis. After multiple group comparisons, differences between groups were tested with pairwise t-test comparisons. Test results were considered statistically significant at P<0.05. Results No serious intraoperative or postoperative complications were found in the three groups. Postoperative vision with a dilated pupil reached or was higher than preoperative best corrected visual acuity. With normal pupils (5 mm or less), no statistically significant differences were found in visual contrast sensitivity among the three groups with or without glare stimulation. Also with dilated pupils (7 mm or larger), no statistically significant differences were found with or without glare. There were no statistically significant differences among the three groups for waveform spherical aberration C12 under normal pupil conditions. Whereas with dilated pupils, there were no statistically significant differences between the thin femtosecond LASIK and flap LASIK groups. But there were significant differences when the SMILE group was compared with the thin flap LASIK group and femtosecond LASIK group (t=2.942, P<0.01; t=3.264, P<0.01). The C12 values of the SMILE group(0.422±0.123) were smaller than the thin flap LASIK group (0.577±0.147) and femtosecond LASIK group (0.606±0.158) under both pupil conditions. Conclusion Compared with “trim” thin flap LASIK and femtosecond LASIK that involved a transition region, full femtosecond microlens removal without an optical ablation zone trim design had no obvious effect on postoperative visual quality.
Objective To investigate the objective optical quality and intraocular scatter after femtosecond laser and mechanical microkeratome LASIK for myopia correction. Methods This was a retrospective study. Seventy-two myopic eyes of 72 patients who conformed to the criteria for LASIK in preoperative examinations were enrolled. Patients had a best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) of ≥1.0. Thirty-five eyes of 35 patients were treated with LASIK with femtosecond laser flap preparation (F-LASIK), male∶female ratio=1∶1.3; 37 eyes of 37 patients were enrolled in the control group with microkeratome flap preparation (M-LASIK), male∶female ratio=1∶2.7. Optical quality parameters were measured in each patient 1 year after the LASIK surgeries: modulation transfer function cutoff frequency (MTFcutoff, cycles per degree, c/d), Strehl2D ratio (SR) and objective scatter index (OSI). Results Mean age was 26.71±5.89 years in the F-LASIK group and 28.67±6.62 years in the M-LASIK group; mean spherical equivalent refraction (SE) was -6.18±2.25 D in the F-LASIK group and -6.62±1.78 D in the M-LASIK group. Neither group had a reduction in BCVA. The safety index was 1.06±0.12 in the F-LASIK group and 1.05±0.14 in the M-LASIK group (t=0.382, P>0.05), while the efficacy index was 1.04±0.15 in the F-LASIK group and 1.04±0.14 in the M-LASIK group (t=0.156, P>0.05). Mean postoperative MTFcutoff was 33.44±6.77 c/d after F-LASIK, which was significantly greater than the mean value of 29.14±9.08 c/d in the M-LASIK (t=2.264, P<0.05); mean SR was 0.18±0.01 in the F-LASIK, which was significantly greater than the mean value of 0.16±0.01 in the M-LASIK (t=2.439, P<0.05). Mean OSI was similar between the two groups, with 0.77±0.39 in the F-LASIK group and 1.07±0.63 in the the M-LASIK group (Z=-1.809, P>0.05). Conclusion Patients acquire better objective optical quality after femtosecond laser LASIK. However, further study is needed to investigate the factors associated with MTFcutoff and intraocular scatter.
Objective To investigate the causes and the treatments of the complications from femtosecond laser flap creation for LASIK. Methods This clinical study of intraoperative and postoperative complications involved 2352 eyes of 1187 myopic and astigmatic patients who underwent FEMTO LDV femtosecond laser flap creation for LASIK between December 2009 and October 2013. Results Three months postoperatively, 94.64% of UCVA reached 1.0 or above and 92.81% of spherical equivalent refractions were ±0.5 D. Thirty-eight eyes of 35 patients developed complications, among them, 11 eyes had decentered or short flaps (0.47%), 2 eyes had button holes (0.08%), 1 eye had a loose flap (0.04%), 3 eyes had flaps with an incomplete margin (0.13%), 3 eyes had flaps with an irregular margin (0.13%), 2 eyes had an incomplete interlayer keratectomy (0.08%), 2 eyes had major epithelial sloughing (0.08%), 3 eyes had a vertical gas breakthrough (0.13%), 4 eyes had an opaque bubble layer (0.17%), 1 eye had a postoperative macular hemorrhage (0.04%), 2 eyes had viral keratitis (0.08%), and 4 eyes had subepithelial haze (0.17%). All patients had satisfactory clinical results with proper intraoperative and/or postoperative treatment. Conclusion Although FEMTO LDV femtosecond laser flap creation for LASIK is relatively safe, efficacious and predictable, the prevention of complications is still important.